Writing by Dr. Dannielle Blumenthal

Photo: Screenshot from interview released on X by Comrawire.

In the fraught landscape of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, allegations of sexual violence demand our utmost attention and scrutiny. These claims, when credible, expose horrific abuses of power and human rights violations that no society should tolerate. However, in highly politicized environments, such narratives can sometimes be amplified or framed in ways that serve broader agendas, potentially undermining genuine victims.

The Incident

Anna Liedtke, a 25-year-old German journalist, was aboard the “Conscience” vessel as part of the Freedom Flotilla Coalition’s effort to deliver aid to Gaza and challenge Israel’s naval blockade. The flotilla was intercepted by Israeli forces in international waters, about 100 nautical miles from Gaza, on October 8, 2025. Liedtke and others were detained for five days before being deported on October 12. German journalist Anna Liedtke has publicly accused Israeli forces of raping her during this time.

While her story deserves serious consideration, there are compelling reasons to question whether it’s being weaponized as part of an anti-Israel campaign—particularly given the flotilla’s ties to Hamas operatives and its apparent focus on generating provocative optics rather than delivering substantial aid.

Liedtke’s Words

In one speech at the International Solidarity Conference with Political Prisoners in Paris on December 20-21, 2025 (organized by the Prisoners’ Voice Platform, or TSP), Liedtke described her experience. This was quickly followed by an interview released by the Palestinian-Leftist “media outlet” “Comrawire” on December 26, 2025 (e.g., “Comrade Wire”).

Transcript 1: Conference Speech

“Hello, as a journalist. I was on the journalist and medical boat and the conscience on the way to Gaza this fall. Around 100 Naurika Maaswe from the coast of Gaza, we were intercepted. We were put into prison for five days. And in this speech, as a woman, I want to talk about the sexual violence I experienced in prison. I do not want to talk about it just to put the focus on myself, because it is nothing personal. It is nothing individual, and it is nothing that I should be ashamed about. We were transferred from one prison to another, and during the strip searches, I was raped. I’m sharing this again, to say it again, not just for me, and not just because I’m the only one that experienced it, because this is not true. I’m sharing it for all the women who experienced sexual violence and sexual torture in the prisons, for all the women who have experienced similar, horrible things in the prison, and probably are experiencing them right now as we’re speaking on this conference. I’m speaking of behalf of those who did not survive those attacks, those who cannot speak about it, because they are still in prison. And again, I am not the one that should feel ashamed. It is the Zionist states and its prisons, his guards, who should feel ashamed. But on the other hand, there’s nothing else to expect from states like those. A couple of times we heard from Palestinian prisoners, especially from female prisoners, about the situation in the Zionist prison. And so what else should we expect from Zionist prisons, from Zionist fascist states? One thing is very important. It did not break my world. There are so many role models, so many women comrades, so many brave women. I take a lot of strength from. And looking back at history, women have always been stronger than that. And I will end my speech with the saying this. I will not stop fighting for justice, in the end of violence, until every woman is free, and has received justice. I will not stop fighting at a better time.”

Source: Liedtke, Anna. 2025. “Testimony on Sexual Violence in Israeli Detention.” Speech presented at the International Solidarity Conference with Political Prisoners, organized by the Prisoners’ Voice Platform (TSP), Paris, France, December 20–21. Quoted in “TÜDAY’dan ZORA Temsilcisi Anna Liedtke ile Dayanışma Açıklaması.” Avegkon, December 22, 2025. https://avegkon.com/2025/12/22/tudaydan-zora-temsilcisi-anna-liedtke-ile-dayanisma-aciklamasi/.

Transcript 2: Interview and “Promotional” Video

This interview with Comrawire features video of Israel supposedly torturing Palestinians.

“I myself experienced sexual violence while being transferred from one prison to the other. My name is Anna, I’m 25 years old. I’m from Germany. I participated in the Freedom Floteler Coalition this year. I’m a journalist, I was on the boat, the conscience. We were intercepted by the IOF while being transferred from kids here to Devon. They did the strict searches. And I was raped during that. I’m sharing this and not for me, but for all the people who cannot talk about it. Palestinians in the Zionist eyes are not viewed as humans, as cruel as it sounds, so this is why I’m sharing it. Because as a journalist going into those prisons, I think now is my task to also share this publicly and to say, I don’t have to be ashamed and I’m not ashamed that this happened to me. I just want the world once more to know what’s going on inside those Zionist prisons. They don’t care about any international law, human rights law, about any conventions. Justice for what I have experienced is much bigger than just the people who did this to me being punished. Justice would mean an end of Zionism and end of the occupation and end of genocide and end of those prison systems and end of all the violence. Justice in the end means liberation of Palestine. So in the end, yes, I will. I will get justice. The patriarchal system is so deeply rooted in those Zionist prison systems to break the will of especially and mostly Palestinian prisoners. The most important thing is that your struggle continues, your fight continues. If you’re confronted with those IOF soldiers, they are this small. They don’t have anything but their guns and their Zionist beliefs. There really is no reason to be afraid. There’s woman solidarity that is so much stronger. I am calling everyone onto the streets in front of the embassies to say yes. Palestine belongs to the Palestinians and our bodies belong to us. Whenever we experience this kind of violence, the best thing we can do and of course also the most revolutionary thing we can do is not to be silent about it.”

Source: Comrawire, Interview with Anna Liedtke, released December 26, 2025 on X https://x.com/comrawire/status/2004527247601066272?s=20

Notably, the two transcripts are remarkably similar in structure, phrasing, and talking points—almost identical in key elements.

Both emphasize the systemic nature of the violence, tie it directly to anti-Zionist rhetoric, express a lack of personal shame, and pivot to calls for Palestinian liberation and continued resistance.

This similarity suggests a rehearsed or scripted narrative, potentially crafted to maximize political impact rather than reflect spontaneous personal reflection.

The composed delivery in both, with minimal visible trauma and a focus on empowerment and activism, further underscores this pattern.

Drilling down, when comparing these two transcripts, there is a clear structural and thematic overlap that suggests the use of consistent talking points.

1. De-Individualization of Trauma: In both, Liedtke immediately pivots away from the personal nature of the assault to frame it as a collective experience. (T1: “nothing personal… nothing individual” / T2: “not for me, but for all the people”).
2. The Shared Rejection of “Shame”: The specific phrase “not ashamed” appears in both as a key rhetorical anchor. In trauma recovery, moving past shame is a long process; here, it is presented as an immediate, revolutionary stance.
3. Direct Linguistic Parallels: Specific phrases are repeated almost verbatim:

• Context: “transferred from one prison to another” (T1) vs. “transferred from one prison to the other” (T2).
• Goal: “break the will” (T1: “did not break my world” / T2: “to break the will of… Palestinian prisoners”).
• Definition of Justice: In both, justice is defined not by the punishment of the individual perpetrators, but by the “end of Zionism.”

Prior False Claims

In many of these cases—including Liedtke’s—the narrative of “systemic violence” only emerges fully after release.

• Greta Thunberg (Sept/Oct 2025): Detained aboard the Global Sumud flotilla, Thunberg and fellow activists alleged “repeated physical and mental abuse,” including dehydration and beatings. However, Israeli Foreign Ministry footage showed activists being provided with water and rain gear. While Thunberg alleged sleep deprivation and harsh conditions in Ketziot Prison, Swedish consular officials who visited her noted that deportation procedures were followed according to law.
• Rima Hassan (June & Oct 2025): The French MEP reported being “beaten” by police during the October interception of the Madleen. While these claims were widely circulated by activist outlets, Israeli authorities maintained that all legal rights were upheld and no formal medical complaints were filed during the actual detention period.

Mistreating high-profile European journalists or politicians would be strategically counter-productive, as it would provide a massive propaganda victory for the very groups Israel is trying to contain.

Hamas Ties to the Flotilla

At the heart of this story is the Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC). Israeli intelligence and reports reveal deep links to Hamas, with key organizer Zaher Birawi designated as a Hamas operative by Israel and the UK. Documents captured in Gaza show Hamas’s “direct involvement” with flotilla leaders.

Israeli officials note that flotillas like these carry minimal aid and reject offers to transfer supplies peacefully, suggesting the real goal is to create international incidents and “optics” of Israeli aggression. By intercepting in international waters, Israel plays into a narrative of brutality—exactly the publicity these operations seek. In Liedtke’s case, her allegation emerges from this specific context, raising questions about whether the mission was designed to provoke such claims for the purpose of global headlines.

Politicizing Personal Trauma

Several elements suggest Liedtke’s narrative is being leveraged as a tool in a larger propaganda effort:

• Heavy Politicization: Liedtke doesn’t frame her experience as an isolated crime but explicitly links it to the “end of Zionism.” She asks, “What else should we expect from Zionist prisons?” This mirrors a pattern where allegations are used to paint the state as inherently evil.
• Selective Amplification: Despite the gravity of the claims, there’s a conspicuous lack of coverage in Western media. Reporting comes almost exclusively from activist outlets like Comrawire (an anti-imperialist, Marxist-aligned source) and Turkish sites.
• The Motive of Optics: Israel is under intense international scrutiny. Mistreating a high-profile German journalist during a five-day detention would provide no tactical advantage and would only amplify negative global optics, making the allegation strategically counter-intuitive for the state.

The Germans’ Guilt

For a German journalist—especially one shaped by a culture of Vergangenheitsbewältigung (wrestling with the past)—the intersection of national guilt and modern activism creates a unique psychological vulnerability. For many in this demographic, the Holocaust is not just a historical event but a moral “ground zero” that mandates a lifelong commitment to “never again.”

However, a specific shift often occurs within leftist circles: the moral imperative to protect the persecuted is transferred from the Jewish victims of the 1940s to the Palestinian subjects of the present. By championing the Palestinian cause, a German journalist can feel they are finally “on the right side of history,” effectively externalizing their inherited guilt. This creates a powerful, sometimes blinding, emotional tether; the more she views the Palestinian struggle through the lens of a “new Holocaust” or “colonial genocide,” the more she can feel she is atoning for her ancestors’ crimes. This “guilt-redemption” cycle can lead to a dangerous suspension of skepticism, making her particularly susceptible to the narratives of groups like the Freedom Flotilla, where the desire to be a “moral hero” may outweigh the professional duty to remain objective or recognize the complexities of the conflict.

Broader Activist Patterns: Selective Outrage

Pro-Palestinian activism often highlights alleged Israeli rapes while downplaying or denying documented sexual violence by Hamas on October 7, 2023. Furthermore, critics point out that many feminist groups highlighting these cases have largely ignored the sexual assault crises in Europe linked to migration.

For instance, in Sweden, nearly two-thirds of convicted rapists are migrants or their descendants, and in the UK, a quarter of convictions involve foreign nationals as of 2025. By cherry-picking narratives like Liedtke’s to fit a specific anti-Zionist agenda while ignoring other victims of sexual violence, activists risk becoming unwitting participants in a broader political game.

Geopolitical Context

The claim is part of a calculated list of patterns used to invert historical truths and delegitimize the state:

• Genocide: Accusing Israel of “genocide” in Gaza—despite the term’s origins in the Holocaust—equates targeted military responses to the Nazis’ systematic extermination of six million Jews, diluting the Holocaust’s unique horror.
• Occupiers: Branding Israel as “occupiers” reframes its defensive presence as imperial aggression, echoing antisemitic canards of Jews as rootless invaders while ignoring indigenous ties.
• Apartheid: Likening security policies to South Africa’s racial segregation system portrays Palestinians as the ultimate victims, sidelining the Jewish experience of centuries of pogroms and exile.
• Mirroring Sexual Violence: Accusing Israel of systematic sexual violence specifically to mirror and neutralize the documented, widespread sexual atrocities committed by Hamas on October 7, 2023, creating a false moral equivalence.

Of course, the calculated appropriation not only garners international sympathy for Hamas but also weaponizes Jewish trauma against the Jewish state, fostering a false equivalence that erodes historical truth in service of extremist goals.

A Critical Perspective

Critics argue that a segment of Western liberal feminism has undergone a profound ideological shift, increasingly prioritizing the aesthetics of intersectional ‘liberation’ over a consistent defense of universal women’s rights. This perspective suggests that many have become ideologically captured by a narrative of Palestinian resistance that overlooks—or actively obscures—the fundamental systemic repressions faced by women and LGBTQ+ individuals within those same frameworks. By aligning themselves with movements whose core tenets often stand in direct opposition to liberal egalitarianism, these advocates are seen as trading objective human rights advocacy for a performative, cult-like adherence to a singular geopolitical cause, ultimately compromising the moral clarity of the feminist project.

And Now We Understand Why She Would Lie

It is within this framework of ideological absolute that the traditional boundaries of journalistic and ethical integrity begin to dissolve.

When a movement is framed as an existential ‘fight for liberation,’ some advocates—including those in the media—may come to view objective truth not as a professional requirement, but as a secondary concern to the ‘higher truth’ of the cause. In this context, even the fabrication of an allegation as grave as sexual violence can be rationalized as a necessary tool of resistance.

By their own admission, such actors justify these falsehoods as legitimate ‘exaggerations’ intended to arouse fervor or maintain the narrative momentum of the struggle, operating under the dangerous assumption that the nobility of the end justifies the dishonesty of the means.

Conclusion: Caution and the Search for Truth

Allegations of sexual violence are among the most serious that can be leveled. If true, Liedtke’s claims add to a disturbing body of evidence regarding detention conditions that must be addressed by international bodies like the UN or ICC.

However, when a personal assault is immediately and systematically tied to a call for the “end of Zionism,” it suggests an intent to inflame rather than solely seek accountability. We must demand independent probes and medical evidence while remaining wary of how personal trauma is drafted into the service of geopolitical warfare.

Sources

Avegkon. “TÜDAY’dan ZORA Temsilcisi Anna Liedtke ile Dayanışma Açıklaması.” Avegkon, December 22, 2025. https://avegkon.com/2025/12/22/tudaydan-zora-temsilcisi-anna-liedtke-ile-dayanisma-aciklamasi/.

BirGün. “İsrail’de Gözaltındaki Alman Kadın Aktiviste Cinsel Saldırı.” BirGün, 2025. https://www.birgun.net/haber/israil-de-gozaltindaki-alman-kadin-aktiviste-cinsel-saldiri-678872.

Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ). “Anna Liedtke.” Committee to Protect Journalists. Accessed December 2025. https://cpj.org/data/people/anna-liedtke/.

Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ). “Israel Frees 14 Journalists Detained from Gaza-Bound Freedom Flotilla.” Committee to Protect Journalists, October 2025. https://cpj.org/2025/10/israel-frees-14-journalists-detained-from-gaza-bound-freedom-flotilla/.

Comrawire, Interview with Anna Liedtke, released December 26, 2025 on X https://x.com/comrawire/status/2004527247601066272?s=20

Drop Site News (@DropSiteNews). X post. December 2025. https://x.com/DropSiteNews/status/1874089586562035951.

i24NEWS. “Court Records Show Greta Thunberg Made No Complaints in Israeli Detention.” i24NEWS, October 5, 2025. https://www.i24news.tv/en/news/israel/diplomacy/artc-court-records-show-greta-thunberg-made-no-complaints-in-israeli-detention.

İLKHA (Ilke News Agency). “German Journalist Says She Was Sexually Assaulted in Israeli Custody.” İLKHA, December 26, 2025. https://ilkha.com/english/world/german-journalist-says-she-was-sexually-assaulted-in-israeli-custody-500350.

Israel Desert Unit 777 (@IsraelDesertUnit777). Telegram post. October 20, 2025. https://web.telegram.org/k/#@IsraelDesertUnit777.

Jewish Chronicle. “Jerusalem Denies Abuse of Thunberg, Others Arrested Aboard Hamas Flotilla.” Jewish Chronicle, October 5, 2025. https://jewishchronicle.timesofisrael.com/jerusalem-denies-abuse-of-thunberg-others-arrested-aboard-hamas-flotilla/.

Liedtke, Anna. 2025. “Testimony on Sexual Violence in Israeli Detention.” Speech presented at the International Solidarity Conference with Political Prisoners, organized by the Prisoners’ Voice Platform (TSP), Paris, France, December 20–21. Quoted in “TÜDAY’dan ZORA Temsilcisi Anna Liedtke ile Dayanışma Açıklaması.” Avegkon, December 22, 2025. https://avegkon.com/2025/12/22/tudaydan-zora-temsilcisi-anna-liedtke-ile-dayanisma-aciklamasi/.

Marginalia Subversiva (@marginaliasubversiva). Threads post. December 2025. https://www.threads.com/@marginaliasubversiva/post/DSr5RFIFDDO/rape-is-not-collateral-damage-it-is-a-war-crime-when-deployed-systematically-it.

Perspektive Online. “Vergewaltigung in Israelischer Gefangenschaft: ‘Es hat Meinen Willen Nicht Gebrochen.’” Perspektive Online, December 2025. https://perspektive-online.net/2025/12/vergewaltigung-in-israelischer-gefangenschaft-es-hat-meinen-willen-nicht-gebrochen/.

Politika Haber. “İsrail’de Alman Kadın Aktiviste Cinsel Saldırı.” Politika Haber, 2025. https://politikahaber.com/israilde-alman-kadin-aktiviste-cinsel-saldiri/.

Prisoners’ Voice Platform. “‘We Were Transferred from One Prison to Another, and During the Strip Searches I Was Raped.’” Prisoners’ Voice Platform. Accessed December 2025. https://prisonersvoice.org/en/we-were-transferred-from-one-prison-to-another-and-during-the-strip-searches-i-was-raped/.

The Times of Israel. “Documents from Gaza Show Hamas’s ‘Direct Involvement’ with Aid Flotilla, Israel Claims.” The Times of Israel, September 30, 2025. https://www.timesofisrael.com/documents-from-gaza-show-hamass-direct-involvement-with-aid-flotilla-israel-claims/.

The Jerusalem Post. “Gaza Flotilla Organization Founder Linked to Hamas by Israel, UK.” The Jerusalem Post, 2025. https://www.jpost.com/international/article-857267.

The Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center. “The Global Sumud (‘Perseverance’) Flotilla in the Service of Hamas.” The Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center, September 4, 2025. https://www.terrorism-info.org.il/en/the-global-sumud-perseverance-flotilla-in-the-service-of-hamas/.

Global Influence Operations Report. “New Gaza Flotilla Vessel Sails: Freedom Flotilla Coalition Has Deep Ties to Hamas.” Global Influence Operations Report, July 18, 2025. https://www.global-influence-ops.com/new-gaza-flotilla-vessel-sails-freedom-flotilla-coalition-has-deep-ties-to-hamas/.

Lund University. “Nearly Two Thirds of Convicted Rapists in Sweden Are Migrants or Their Descendants.” Lund University, 2025. https://portal.research.lu.se/en/activities/nearly-two-thirds-of-convicted-rapists-in-sweden-are-migrants-or-/.

Migration Central. “2025 Illegal Migration Crime Audit.” Migration Central, November 3, 2025. https://www.migrationcentral.co.uk/p/2025-illegal-migration-crime-audit.

Spiked. “Why Are Feminists Dismissing Women’s Fears about Migrant Crime?” Spiked, August 27, 2025. https://www.spiked-online.com/2025/08/27/why-are-feminists-dismissing-womens-fears-about-migrant-crime/.

X post (@anadoluagency). December 2025. https://x.com/anadoluagency/status/1974654103201706263?s=20.

X post (@comrawire). December 26, 2025. https://x.com/comrawire/status/2004527247601066272?s=20.

Yemen Press Agency. “German Journalist Accuses Israeli Forces of Rape After Freedom Flotilla Interception.” Yemen Press Agency, December 2025. https://en.ypagency.net/380281.

Written with the help of Grok and Gemini AI.