People keep saying Stephen Miller’s policies are the bulwark against Muslim invaders, against an invasion that will swallow the country if it is not stopped.
The fear is real. It is also blinding.
Fear makes any cruelty look like defense, and once cruelty looks like defense, nobody asks what the person ordering it actually believes. This post is about that question. It is written from my position — I support President Trump, and I repudiate Stephen Miller’s leadership — and it argues that Miller’s cruelty and racism are not side effects of his policy stances. They are the stances. Character matters, and the record is the evidence.
The record starts early, and it starts with race. At thirteen, Miller read Guns & Ammo magazine, then Wayne LaPierre’s Guns, Crime, and Freedom, and concluded that American culture was “under assault from outsiders.” In high school he told a classmate, Maria Vivanco, to “speak only English,” and taunted new immigrants struggling with the language. He had a close friend in middle school, Jason Islas, a Mexican-American, who says Miller called him one day to end their friendship because of Jason’s Latino heritage. “It was just a strange day, and I’ll never forget it,” Islas said.
At Duke, where he entered in 2003, he wrote columns attacking multiculturalism and affirmative action, befriended Richard Spencer, then a graduate student who would found the alt-right, and Peter Brimelow, author of Alien Nation and founder of VDARE, and called into a radio show to claim that “terrorists were recruiting members of the Muslim Students Association.”
None of this is a policy position. It is a worldview, formed before he held any office, and it has not changed.
The clearest window into that worldview is the set of more than 900 emails Miller sent to Breitbart editors between March 2015 and June 2016, leaked by former Breitbart editor Katie McHugh and investigated by the Southern Poverty Law Center’s Hatewatch. More than 80 percent of the emails relate to race or immigration. Miller urged Breitbart to draw parallels between the Pope’s remarks on borders and Jean Raspail’s Camp of the Saints, a novel about a nonwhite invasion of Europe; he pushed stories from VDARE, a site founded by Brimelow, and from American Renaissance; he invoked Calvin Coolidge and the eugenics-based Immigration Act of 1924 repeatedly. Hatewatch’s finding was blunt: it found no example of Miller writing sympathetically, or even neutrally, about any nonwhite or foreign-born person.
McHugh confirmed the exchanges to the Washington Post, which did not independently verify the entire collection; the White House called the SPLC an “utterly discredited, long-debunked far-left smear organization”; more than 80 Democratic members of Congress called for Miller’s resignation.
The emails are not a smear. They are his own words, in his own voice, before he had power to enforce them.
In power, the worldview became policy, and the policy kept the same shape.
During family separation, Miller’s then-girlfriend and later wife Katie Waldman, the Department of Homeland Security spokeswoman, told Jacob Soboroff that “the intention of putting children in cages was to shock.”
In May 2025, as White House deputy chief of staff, Miller called habeas corpus a “privilege” that “can be suspended in time of invasion,” and said whether the president would act “depends on whether the courts do the right thing or not.”
The Constitution’s suspension clause does not name who may invoke it, but the resounding consensus among legal scholars is that Congress has to sign off — as Justice Amy Coney Barrett has also said — and, in the words of attorney Marc Elias, “Congress has the authority to suspend habeas corpus — not Stephen Miller, not the president.”
The writ has been suspended only four times in American history: by Lincoln during the Civil War, in the Philippines in 1905, in Hawaii after Pearl Harbor, and in 1871 against the KKK. Miller wanted it on the table for migrants.
The same instinct shows in an April 2018 conversation reported by former Homeland Security appointee Miles Taylor in his book Blowback.
According to Taylor, Miller asked Coast Guard Commandant Admiral Paul Zukunft: “Why…can’t we just use Predator drones to blow up the migrant boats?” Pressed, Miller said the United States launched airstrikes on terrorists “all the time” and retaliated against pirates off Somalia, and, in Taylor’s account, “wasn’t interested in the moral conflict of drone-bombing migrants. He wanted to know whether anyone could stop America from doing it.” Admiral Zukunft explained the difference: America attacked enemy forces when they were armed and posed an imminent threat; seafaring migrants were generally unarmed civilians.
Miller’s spokesman called the account “a complete fiction that exists only in the mind of Miles Taylor, desperate to stay relevant.”
Rolling Stone, which first reported it, said it reviewed written documentation from during the Trump administration that supports Taylor’s account, and that multiple people intimately familiar with the matter confirmed it.
The claim is contested. What is not contested is the pattern: the question was asked, and the only objection that mattered to Miller was whether anyone could stop it.
Evan Segal, writing on Substack, calls Miller “the architect of cruelty” and argues the cruelty is the point — deterrence through suffering, from family separation to the detention conditions at Dilley, Texas.
He describes the January 2026 killings in Minneapolis of Renée Nicole Macklin Good, shot by ICE agent Jonathan Ross, and Alex Pretti, and frames them as the predictable end of a politics that treats migrants as an invading force.
The official accounts of those killings, and the video evidence, remain contested, and this post does not present Segal’s framing as a finding. What the record establishes on its own is the language: “invasion,” “conquest,” “America is for Americans and Americans only” — the rhetoric of a war against people who are, in the main, unarmed civilians seeking entry.
Zero tolerance, the 2017 travel orders, family separation: the cruelty was not a failure of the policy. It was the policy, administered by a man whose record shows he has always seen outsiders as a threat to be punished, not people to be governed.
In November 2026, after a Democratic midterm blowout, Miller was appointed White House chief of staff, replacing Susie Wiles.
Vanity Fair’s Chris Whipple describes him as “a zealot, a hard-boiled ideologue — an advocate of Trump’s notorious first-term Muslim ban, family separation, and mass deportations,” and “the antithesis of Ronald Reagan’s chief James Baker, a cool pragmatist who could push back.”
Miller once decreed that the president’s powers “are very substantial and will not be questioned.”
He is now, in Whipple’s words, “the official charged with questioning the president’s decisions.”
Asked whether the job involves telling the president what he does not want to hear, Miller answered: “No, I wouldn’t say that.”
The closed circle is literal now as well as figurative: he and Katie live and entertain on a fortified military post south of the White House, hosting Cabinet officials behind gates, at parties their circle calls “MAGA’s Petit Trianon.”
Power, insulated from the people it governs, answering to no one who would push back.
There is a darker thread, and it has to be handled with the care it demands.
Heather Wellington, who identifies as a survivor of Epstein’s trafficking network, says that major public officials are vetted through sexual blackmail — that obtaining compromising material on a candidate is itself part of vetting, because candidates who are “blackmailable” are more attractive precisely because they can be controlled.
She claims a secret section of Project 2025, which she calls “Project Rahab,” is a framework for using sex spies, trafficking, intelligence gathering, and blackmail to advance an extreme Christian political agenda, and that more than a dozen men who trafficked her were contributors or co-authors of Project 2025. Note that Miller was not one of them, and the claim is uncorroborated.
Alleged trafficking survivor Jessica Leigh Collins, in her own account, names Miller directly. On an archived version of her personal website, jessicaleighcollins.com, she wrote: “Photo outside Gate 3 of the Naval Academy where I was trafficked to Senator John McCain, White House Senior Advisor Stephen Miller, Harvey Weinstein, Hunter Biden, and many others at my apartments 9 and 11 located at 2 Maryland Avenue, Annapolis, Md 20137.”
That is Collins’s self-published claim. It does not appear in her court filing — in Collins v. United States. There, Miller’s name appears with no place, date, or incident attached to him anywhere in the complaint or the exhibits — and the case was dismissed in February 2025, the court holding that the complaint “lacks an arguable basis in law or fact.” It has not been independently verified, and this post does not present it as fact.
What is worth saying, plainly, is that two separate accounts, from two women who do not know each other, point at the same mechanism: sexual compromise used as leverage over people in public life. The convergence is suggestive. It is not proof.
Speaking up against Miller’s behavior is not about hating the president, or the country, or the idea of a border. I am a Trump supporter, a proud Jew, a patriot, a nationalist, and a populist. I write this because the Torah bans cruelty, and because hatred is not patriotic and will always backfire.
Racism is a disorder.
A man who ended a friendship because his friend was Latino, who told a classmate to speak only English, who spent his twenties promoting white-nationalist literature to the press, who asked whether drones could blow up migrant boats and whether habeas corpus could be suspended for migrants, is not a thinker whose ideas happen to be harsh. He is a man whose harshness is the idea.
The policies are not the bulwark. They are the expression of the character. And character matters — in a chief of staff, it matters more than anywhere, because there is no one left to question the decisions.
The fear that blinds people to this is understandable. It is also the thing that has to be answered, with the record, in full, before more of it is enforced.
Bibliography
Blumenthal, Dannielle. “Stephen Miller’s Racism Is Not Patriotic.” Substack, November 15, 2026.
Blumenthal, Dannielle. Untitled note on Stephen Miller. Substack, November 17, 2026.
Segal, Evan J. “The Architect of Cruelty: Stephen Miller, the Psychopath in Power.” Substack.
Hayden, Michael Edison. “Stephen Miller’s Affinity for White Nationalism Revealed in Leaked Emails.” Southern Poverty Law Center, Hatewatch, November 12, 2019. https://www.splcenter.org/resources/hatewatch/stephen-millers-affinity-white-nationalism-revealed-leaked-emails/
Herchenroeder, Katie. “Trump Administration Looking to Deprive Migrants of Habeas Corpus.” Vanity Fair, May 10, 2025. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/story/trump-administration-looking-to-deprive-migrants-of-habeas-corpus
Levin, Bess. Vanity Fair, June 27, 2023. On Miller’s April 2018 question about Predator drones and migrant boats, as reported by Miles Taylor. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2023/06/stephen-miller-migrant-boats
Peretz, Evgenia. “Stephen Miller and His Wife Found Love in a Hateful Place.” Vanity Fair, August 13, 2020. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2020/08/stephen-miller-and-his-wife-found-love-in-a-hateful-place
Whipple, Chris. Vanity Fair, November 10, 2026. On Miller’s appointment as White House chief of staff and Susie Wiles’s resignation. https://www.vanityfair.com/story/stephen-miller-susie-wiles-interviews
McLaughlin, Aidan. Vanity Fair, October 8, 2026. On Katie Miller as MAGA Washington hostess. https://www.vanityfair.com/story/stephen-miller-wife-katie-maga-washington-hostess
Levin, Bess. Vanity Fair, March 18, 2021. On Miller after the first Trump administration and his appearance with Representative Mo Brooks. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/03/stephen-miller-mo-brooks
Green Neighbour. “Heather Wellington’s Extraordinary Allegations.” Substack, September 3, 2026. https://greenneighbour.substack.com/p/heather-wellingtons-extraordinary. Commentary and summary of Wellington’s video presentation; a derivative publication, not an independent witness.
Collins, Jessica Leigh. Archived version of jessicaleighcollins.com.
Collins v. United States, No. 1:25-cv-00228 (D.D.C.). Complaint and exhibits. Memorandum Opinion, Doc. 12, February 3, 2025 (dismissal).